Picky.
As long as I’m on the topic of food, let me reveal some of my not-always-logical food preferences.
Things I like cooked but not raw: Onions, tomatoes
Things I like raw but not cooked: Capsicum (bell peppers), carrots, cabbage
Things I like pureed but not whole: Mushrooms (I like the flavor but the spongy texture bothers me)
Things I like on their own but not mixed in with other things: Sultanas (raisins), and most other dried fruit
Things I absolutely refused to eat until an epiphany a few months ago: Offal
Things I still refuse to eat and cannot forsee any circumstances that will change that: Insects
Things I will eat if the only other choice is starving or offending someone, but I won’t be happy about it: Seafood, spinach, brussels sprouts
Flavors that make me gag: Anise, caraway, marzipan
I’m with you on the onions: fried with a steak or sandwich? Great. Nice crispy ones in a burger? Wonderful. Raw? Blech!
Bell peppers, I like cooked but not raw, and mushrooms I generally like whole. Offal … I’m not sure I’ve ever actually tried heart, your epiphany sounds like a great meal though.
Marzipan’s a funny one: I can’t stand it, except the thin layer you get as part of fruitcake frosting, which I really like.